He currently plays for SS Virtus, wearing the number 25 shirt. He plays primarily as a Forward. His current market value is estimated at 100K €.

His most recent move was a from ASD Savignanese to SS Virtus on 2022-07-12.

In the San Marino Campionato di Calcio 2025-2026 season, Simone Benincasa scored 3 goals and provided 0 assists across 20 appearances, averaging 0.2 goals per game with 0 shots attempted and 0 on target.